Skip to main content

BMJ Political Analyst comments on Brazil’s Congress revolt over austerity

By 4 de March de 2015February 8th, 2017No Comments

Brazil’s Rousseff races to contain Congress revolt over austerity

(Reuters) – Brazilian President Dilma Rousseff raced on Wednesday to defuse a rebellion by legislators upset about her budget austerity plans and her handling of a corruption scandal at state-run oil company Petrobras.

Rousseff met with legislative leaders from her coalition after they unexpectedly threw out a presidential decree that would have raised payroll taxes and helped close a gaping hole in Brazil’s budget.

‘This is very serious for Rousseff,’ said political analyst Gabriel Petrus of Brasilia-based consultancy Barral M Jorge Associates. ‘It looks as if there is no political stability on top of the economic crisis.’

The economic impact of the congressional maneuver late on Tuesday was unclear, but it was a sign of how fallout from the scandal at Petroleo Brasileiro SA, as Petrobras is formally known, threatens Rousseff’s agenda and could increase the threat of a recession this year.

Rousseff vowed to improve communication with allies before sending more belt-tightening measures to Congress, said lawmakers who met with her. If Congress blocks them, the government will have to make deeper spending cuts elsewhere to meet its fiscal savings target of 1.2 percent of gross domestic product this year, her minister for congressional ties, Pepe Vargas, told reporters.

Brazil’s real tumbled more than 2 percent on Wednesday and briefly hit 3 per dollar for the first time since 2004 as some investors worried the fiscal problems could cause Brazil to lose its investment-grade credit rating. Stocks fell 1.6 percent.

The cost to protect holders of Brazilian government bonds against default for five years through contracts known as credit default swaps rose to 244 basis points on Wednesday, wider than those of peer, junk-rated emerging market nations such as Turkey andIndonesia, according to BNP Paribas Securities.

Brazil’s bonds have traded at around that level for a month, indicating that investors see an imminent downgrade.

Analysts from Standard & Poor’s, which last year downgraded Brazil to the lowest investment-grade rating as public finances deteriorated, are meeting with government officials in Brasilia this week.

The Petrobras scandal erupted last year with the arrest of a black-market currency dealer who described a massive bribery and kickback scheme at the oil company, allegedly involving corrupt executives and politicians.

The scandal threatens to have a ripple effect on Brazil’s already weak economy, prompting Petrobras to halt or cancel several key investment projects. Companies in the energy and construction sectors are also finding it harder to obtain credit.

Rousseff, a leftist who has just started her second term, is also struggling with rising inflation and unemployment, low prices for Brazil’s commodities, and a historic drought that has raised the specter of widespread energy and water rationing.



Rousseff’s latest setback had its roots in two nearly simultaneous events late on Tuesday.

First, Senate President Renan Calheiros, a member of Brazil’s ruling coalition, threw out Rousseff’s austerity decree for what he called procedural reasons.

Hours later, Brazil’s top prosecutor asked the Supreme Court to open investigations into 54 people, most of whom are expected to be politicians accused of benefiting from kickbacks at Petrobras.

Under Brazilian law, only the top court can try cases against political leaders. The list of names was not released.

However, numerous Brazilian media reported that Calheiros was among those under investigation. Folha de S.Paulo said, citing unnamed Calheiros allies, that his opposition to Rousseff’s fiscal decree was a pressure tactic designed to show the government his displeasure at being on the list.

A spokesman for Calheiros said he had no information about his inclusion on the list and would not comment further.

Rousseff’s office said it would send a bill to Congress to replace the decree and raise payroll taxes. Since it is unclear when the increasingly hostile legislature will vote on the bill, however, the tax increase may come later than it would have under the decree.

Eurasia Group, a consultancy, said the delay could cost the government as much as 3 billion reais ($1 billion).

In a sign of Rousseff’s dependency on Congress, Banco Itau calculated that the president would need its support to pass budget savings measures worth 0.5 percent of GDP this year. That would be equivalent to nearly half the government’s primary surplus target, a key gauge of its ability to pay creditors.

(Additional reporting by Caroline Stauffer and Guillermo Parra-Bernal; Writing by Brian Winter; Editing by Todd Benson and Lisa Von Ahn)

Leave a Reply